Perspective of a Roman Soldier

The Slaughtering Soldier

“Then Herod, when he saw that he was mocked of the wise men, was exceeding wroth, and sent forth, and slew all the children that were in Bethlehem, and in all the coasts thereof, from two years old and under, according to the time which he had diligently inquired of the wise men. Then was fulfilled that which was spoken by Jeremy the prophet, saying, In Rama was there a voice heard, lamentation, and weeping, and great mourning, Rachel weeping for her children, and would not be comforted, because they are not.”

—Matthew 2:16-18

Joe Knapp

Question:

If you’d been there, a soldier in the fray,
One taught to take commands and to obey,
If you’d been told to slay the smallest child
Despite the cries of mothers driven wild,
Because you’re told that you and you alone
Can stop the threat against the king’s own throne,
If that’s the role you’re told that you must play,
What trembling thoughts are in your heart today?

Answer:

Yes, I was there that one fateful day;
A very young soldier and new to the fray,
Seeking to show support to the king,
To put down sedition, the threat to his ring,
Eager and willing to do his request,
To secure him his kingdom and my future behest
To receive of his favor a name of renown,
A name feared by all as supporting his crown

Though others around me with years in the fray
Seemed quivering and weak toward their work for that day,
And even our leader, Centurion so called,
While appraising the troops, looked himself quite appalled,
I eagerly awaited to show them my nerve,
Bolstered for certain that I had better serve
And show to King Herod, and show to them all,
That I had more nerve, and more zeal, and more gall.

So we rode forth that day to the town of our call,
Bethlehem by name; but none rode quite as tall
As I, while I dreamt of the fame that would be
To this newest of soldiers, the fearless one, he.
Not even real danger in this type of fray,
For no child nor its mother could call into play
A challenge against one so trained and so armed;
By nerve I’d slay more, and never be harmed.

My sword swung by rote and did it’s cruel deed;
To the blood and cries at first I gave no heed.
I charged with more haste to do more than my share,
Swinging and stabbing as pain filled the air,
Till slowly I tired from the pace I had set,
And slowly the carnage reached into my breast.
It pounded my heart and pressed tight on my air,
And I sank into blackness and fear and despair.

How could I have wreaked such havoc unknown?
How trade such young lives for name or for throne?
I then saw why others had quivered that day
As they faced such revulsion of cowardly fray.
And I vowed I’d learn more of the kingly young boy,
To see if ‘twas his way to build or to destroy.
For surely is man to be nobler in truth,
To defend ‘gainst aggression, but not against youth.

From the Jews over many years I came to know
Of the promised Messiah whom justice would sow;
Who even soon by prophets foreshown
Was to come any day making his kingdom known.
A man so unworthy, so blood-stained as I,
Was then graced by the Savior, who heeded my cry.
One Jesus by name, this Centurion blessed,
Bringing life to my servant who lay in death’s rest.

Then shattered was I when I heard Christ had died,
My faith growing weaker; I faltered and I cried.
But tears turned to joy when I heard he’d arose,
And I asked that he heal me, for he all sorrow knows.
I asked his forgiveness for slaying the youths,
And praised now this king who made known all God’s truths.
I prayed long to serve him, my family, all of us,
Then said Peter, “God calls thee, . . . Cornelius.”

Praise to his name, to his glory, and his love,
That he takes from the lowest and lifts them up above.
One such as I, seeking fame and trained to kill,
Slaughtered so many doing one false king’s will.
Now forgiven and blessed many times and again,
I’m serving the true king who will bless all of men.
My burden he lifted at Calvary, and my sins he has taken away.
He’ll carry your burden too, if to him you sincerely pray.


Editor’s Note: The poet above assumes that Cornelius may have been one of the soldiers assigned by Herod to kill the infants in Bethlehem and environs. This is poetic license. There is nothing in the Bible to either confirm or deny that reality.


“Herod, when he saw that he was mocked of the wise men, was exceeding wroth.” —Matthew 2:16

“No, Herod, thou art not mocked of the wise men, but of a Higher than they. "He that sitteth in the heavens doth laugh at thee; the Lord hath thee in derision." "He disappointeth the devices of the crafty, so that their hands cannot perform their enterprise. He taketh the wise in their own craftiness, and the counsel of the froward is carried headlong" (Psa. 2:4; Job 5:12-13).”

Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown Commentary